HYSTERICAL Dining in a hystorical setting

Call us today  716.372.9606
Kitchen is open 7 days a week till midnight.  Famous for our Steak dinners, jumbo wings, half pound burgers, real steak hoagies and randy's mom's secret beer battered fish fry (friday only) ask about our daily specials!
we have something to satisfy any craving.  --  Carry-out also available.


(5) Chicken Fingers     

(10) Boneless Wing Dings         

Irish Wings = Regular/Large                   

French Fries = Regular/Large           

Waffle Fries = Regular/Large                   

Sweet Potato Fries = Regular/Large (Honey .50 Extra)                   

Mushrooms (10 oz)


Loaded Potato Skins           

Beer Battered Onion Rings         

(10) J-bombs       

(5) Pizza Logs        

(6) Cheese Stix             

(10) Mini Corn Dogs             

(10) Sweet Corn Nuggets               

(12) Mini Tacos                   

Onion Petals

(10) Mac & Cheese Bites                           

Hodge Podge Platter of asst. Deep Fried Finger Foods with dipping sauce

Super Loaded Waffle Fries (taco meat & cheese...enough to share)                      


Loaded Nachos         

Jalapeno & Chedder Pretzel               

Thick Homemade Chili Cup or a Bowl / Cheese extra             

Chili Fries with Cheese

Randy's Famous Wings!

Quantity of:     10's...   15's...   20's...   25's...   50's.... (Mix and Match Sauces - $1.00 per sauce per order)

Smokey BBQ, Honey BBQ, Dry-Rub Mesquite BBQ, Butter & Garlic, Honey Mustard, 24 Karat Gold, 

Happy Hour, Teriyaki, Garlic Buffalo Parmesan, Magic, Crystal; Crack, Enchanted Mountain, 

Mild, Medium, Hot, Hotter than Hell...o how hot so you want these things?

Or try Randy's (Adult Wings)

Jack Daniels BBQ Wings, Tequlia Sweet Chili Wings, Southern Comfort BBQ Wings

Randy's Specialty Burger:

All burgers are 1/2 pound of 100% Fresh, Never Frozen, Ground Beef

Bona Burger:   Bacon Cheeseburger scores big with 24K gold-sauced onion rings heaped on top.  Served with fries fresh from our "Friar"!

Philly Burger:   All the Philly Cheese Steak Fixin's, including the shaved steak, top this all-beef burger for the best of both worlds. Served with Philly Fries

Breakfast All Day:  Burger topped with bacon, egg, cheese, tator tots and sriracha ketchup on a toasted bun. Served with a side of Lucky Charms! (With or without milk)

Nacho Hamburguesa:  Taco seasoned patty smothered with creamy nacho cheese, lettuce, tomato, jalapenos, salsa & sour cream, mounded with crushed Doritos and served with a side of fries and Tex Mex Dip

Basta Burger:  Seasoned with Italian herbs & spices, spread with marinara sauce, under melted mozzarella cheese, pepperoni, black olives, banana peppers, topped with a house salad tossed in Italian dressing and parmesan cheese and finished with a garlic butter toasted bun. Served with Italian fries

Gorilla Burger:  Bacon Cheeseburger caught between two grilled cheese sandwiches. Choice of cheeses, and white or wheat bread (or both). Served with fries or house made chips

King Kong Burger:  CAST....1 lb. of ground beef, 8 slices of cheese, 6 strips of bacon &6 slices of toast.  SET DESIGN...Two - 1/2 lb. Bacon Cheeseburgers served triple decker style between three grilled cheese sandwiches, with lettuce, tomato, onion, mayo & 1 pound of fries

All-American burger always available...Served with homemade chips or french fries

Cheese  Selection: Swiss, Provolone, American, Bleu Marble, Cheddar & Pepper Jack

Randy's Sandwiches & Subs:

Choice of Locally Baked Swatt Roll, Wheat or White Bread.  All come with a choice of House-Made chips or Krinkle Cut Fries & a pickle. 

Cheese Choices: American, Provolone, Cheddar, Swiss, Pepper Jack, Marble Bleu,

Shredded Mozzarella

Chicken Finger


Fish Fillet, Battered

Tuna Melt w/ sliced tomato & cheese

The A-10: Grilled Turkey and Roast Beef topped with crisp bacon, deep fried onion petals, mushrooms, provolone cheese and our house made horsey sauce on a warm & toasty weck roll

Pull My Finger Sandwich: Pulled Pork on top of Che\icken Fingers, spilling out of a toasted bun. Topped with our Award-Winning BBQ Sauce. (or choose one of our other BBQ sauces)

YADA YADA: Grilled Roast Beef, Cheese, Bacon, onion Dip sauce

Beef on Weck: (W.N.Y. Favorite) Thin sliced Top Round Dipped in Au Jus, served with Horseradish

Icelandic Crabcake: Tarter of cocktail sauce or any other topping you can think of

Buffalo Chicken Breast: Fresh 6 oz bonless/skinless chicken breast in a choice of wing sauce. Tell us what seasoning you like and top it with lettuce, tomato, onion & mayo

Jack Hammer: Layers of Ham, Pepperoni, & Cooney's Mountain Mustard between two Grilled Pepper Jack Cheese Sandwiches

Chicken Cordon Bleu: 6oz. chicken breast, sliced ham & Swiss Cheese

Italian Sausage Hoagie: with sauteed peppers & onions

Steak Hoagie: with sauteed peppers & onions

Chicken Hoagie: with sauteed peppers & onions

Philly Cheesesteak: with onion & cheese

Hot Meatball Hero: with Mozzarella cheese

Hot Pizza Grinder: Pepperoni & Cheese

Club Sandwiches

All with Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Mayo, Bacon & Cheese...Your Choice of:



Roast Beef


Subs and Wraps

All subs & wraps made with cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, choice of dressing and Banana Peppers; make it a Platter w/chips or Krinkle Cut Fries.  Choice of 1/2 subs 8" or Whole Subs 16"

Grilled Roast Beef

Hand Cut Grilled Steak



Chicken Finger



Grilled Chicken

Cheeseburger Sub

Steak Peddler Sub: Grilled steak, melted cheese, onion, petals, onion dip, sauce and mayo

The Marilyn: Grilled roast beef, sauteed mushrooms, melted Swiss cheese, Horseradish mayo sauce

*****Add Bacon...$1.00 extra on 1/2 subs, sandwiches or wraps & $2.00 extra on Whole subs*****

​Our Salads:

Randy's Favorite Julienne: Iceberg lettuce mixed with carrots and red cabbage- topped with strips of roast beef, ham, turkey, American, Swiss, Cheddar cheeses, hard-boiled eggs, tomatoes and ONION PETALS!!

Monster Wedge: Quarter head of iceberg lettuce, hard boiled-eggs, red onion, grape tomatoes, bacon, Bleu Cheese crumbles, & House-made croutons 

Caesar Salad: Romaine lettuce, shaved Parmesan cheese, house-made croutons, & Caesar dressing. Served with a fresh lemon wedge.

Add: Grilled chicken   Add: 6 Large grilled shrimp   Add: 1 Crab Cake made with spinach & Parmesan

Taco Salad in an Edible Bowl: Iceberg mix, topped with seasoned ground beef, shredded cheese, black olives, onion, tomatoes, salsa & sour cream

Schwing Salad: Mixed greens, onions, tomatoes, & shredded cheese base, with "Schwings' tossed in your choice of Wing Sauce on top

Pittsburgh Salad: Mixed greens, red onions, grape tomatoes, House-made croutons, French fries & shredded cheese

Add: Grilled Chicken   Add: Grilled Steak   Add: Grilled shrimp

Crispy Chicken Salad: Mixed greens, red onions, grape tomatoes, House-made croutons, mozzarella cheese & strips of breaded chicken fingers dipped in any of our famous wing sauces!!

Dressings: Blue Cheese, Ranch, Poppy Seed, Wishbone Italian, House Italian, Thousand Island, French, Honey Mustard, Cucumber Wasabi, Raspberry Vinegrette, Oil & Vinegar, Balsamic Vinegrette

Southwestern Specials:

Fajitas: Freshly Grilled Steak; Boneless Skinless Chicken Breast or Grilled Shrimp with sauteed peppers and onions, melted cheese, diced fresh tomatoes, lettuce and salsa, rolled in a large, soft flour tortilla....

Taco Sauce also available

Soft Shell Tacos & Burritos: (Made only with freshest ground beef) and served with nacho chips. Tacos include lettuce, tomatoes, cheese, sour cream & salsa...

Regular or Large

QuesadillaGrilled & seasoned steak, chicken, veggies or cheese with sauteed hot or sweet peppers, onions mozzarella & provolone cheese baked between two flour tortilla shells 

Regular or Large (Enough to share)

Large Sirloin Steak Taco: Served with nacho chips


All Steaks are grilled to your liking 

All entree's served with choice of 2 sides & a roll 

Sides: Soup, Salad, Mashed or Baked Potatoes or Fries, Cottage Cheese,

Grilled or Steamed Veggies 

16oz. Ribeye

12oz. New York Strip Steak

8oz. Flat Iron

4 Piece Fried Chicken (Leg, Breast, Thigh & Wing)

Smothered Grilled Chicken Breast: Sauteed peppers, onion, mushrooms & provolone cheese

Breaded Clam Strips or Shrimp in A Basket: Breaded clam strips, Popcorn shrimp, deep fried to a golden brown

Crab Cakes (2 Crab Cakes)

Butterfly Shrimp: 6 Large breaded shrimp, deep fried to a golden brown

Grilled Shrimp

Buffalo Style Beer Battered Shrimp 12 large beer battered shrimp coated with your favorite wing sauce (or enjoy em' plain)